Would you baptize someone who had a gay "orientation"?

This week I had an interesting encounter. A middle aged man came into the church to get some food. He had been in before, and this time he also said that he was wanting to meet with me.

 

He had some things that he wanted to share with me. He had some various personal struggles that were giving him a lot of anxiety. He was out of work, and he had always worked before (as an engineer salesman). He had some struggles with some of his family relationships and some health issues in his family. And he wanted to know about the Church of Christ and some of our beliefs--what set us apart from some other churches.

 

So I talked about us being autonomous and about our emphasis upon baptism and the Lord's Supper. In particular, I stressed what baptism is. He related some about his church background. He had not gone much at all growing up, but his sister was a devout Baptist. He then shared how he had believed in God but had never been baptized. And then he talked about how he felt that God had led him to this church. He said that he had been praying to God while driving, and his car just found its way to our church building. He had been touched by those who prayed for him and who had given him food.

 

I told him that I wanted to pray for him about his job situation, anxiety, and family situation, and then I asked him what he thought God wanted him to do in regards to baptism and his spiritual walk. He seemed so open and wanting direction, wanting someone to help direct him spiritually.

 

He then told me that the reason that he had never been baptized was that he was gay. And he wanted to know what I believed about this. I told him that we wanted to take people where they were and reach out to them with love and kindness, because this is what Jesus did with people and that is what God had done with us. I told him that it could be that there is a genetic predisposition towards homosexuality in some people. I have seen research that has shown differences in brain composition, though studies usually show some kind of environmental factor as well. There are people that have a predisposition towards alcoholism, and are hooked after one drink, while others never get addicted. While this would make resisting the sin of alcoholism harder, it was not be right to just give yourself over to it. Would not homosexuality be the same? And that as a guy, I find many women attractive (but none as attractive as my wife, Becki!!)--but that it would not be right for me to go after these impulses. Just because one has sexual impulses, if they are wrong before God, should they be acted upon? The issue does not seem to be "orientation"--what one is inclined or tempted to do--but behavior.

 

I asked him to be able to share some of these thoughts, and I apologized for some of the hatred he had had directed at him in the past. He was very emotional in talking about this. Then I asked him if he would like to study some of the Bible passages on this subject next week and see what God's word said about this. He said that he would. He still believes that God sent him our way for a reason. We then had a prayer together.

 

Throughout our conversation, I tried to treat him with love and kindness, hear the pains and struggles and anxieties that he had, and treat him as a human being. Also throughout the conversation, my mind was racing through various scenarios, as it was clear that he would have been baptized if it had not been for his homosexuality. Right now he is celibate, but has not concluded that it is wrong. But he is open to study. This made me think, o boy, when would it be okay to baptize him? 

  • Would it be okay to baptize a person who was gay and practicing and did not plan to change? 
  • Would it be okay to baptize a person who said that they had homosexual feelings or "orientation," but decided that they would be celibate for the rest of their lives. What if they did not really know if it was wrong or not?
  • Should a person only be baptized if he or she not only decides to be celibate, but also has a completely heterosexual orientation?

To the first question, I think most Bible believing Christians would clear say no. But what about the other questions above? What do you think?

 

Views: 779

Comment

You need to be a member of Missional Outreach Network for the Missional Church to add comments!

Join Missional Outreach Network for the Missional Church

Comment by James Nored on April 7, 2011 at 9:41pm
Ken, thank you for sharing these thoughts. I will be glad to keep you updated on this situation. I went and visited this man's mother this week in the hospital. She had just had surgery. He was very appreciative and said I was just wonderful. I say this to say that it is rather amazing to me that he could feel that way, knowing of our differing beliefs on his lifestyle. But, clearly God is working on him and love and kindness can go a long way.
Comment by Kenneth Ray Rayborn on April 7, 2011 at 6:13pm
James, please let us know how it turns out with this individual. I know I am putting him on my prayer list. God takes no pleasure in a soul being eternally lost and neither do I.
Comment by Kenneth Ray Rayborn on April 7, 2011 at 6:08pm

 

James, the work you are doing is phenomenal and so encouraging to me as a Christian who is striving to be more dedicated and reaching out to people. I love to talk to my fellow workers at Toyota about Jesus and His "good news" gospel! I agree that the first question/scenario is a definite "no" because the person must be repentant and aware that he is lost in his present condition. I think our responsibility is to preach/teach others about Jesus which of course includes being baptized "into Christ" and continue to teach the new babe in Christ more of what God's will is for them as Christians. We have no way of knowing if the person will remain "in Christ" over the years. Trying to determine who will and will not remain faithful to the end is beyond us and as long as the person believes the gospel, repents, confesses Jesus as his Lord and Savior and is baptized "into Christ", we are obligated by the great commission to baptize the person and not forget about them but to continue to teach them as babes in Christ. Too many people have been baptized into Christ over the years and then basically left on their own in a world full of "wolves" ready to devour them! You have really helped me see this "gay" issue from a different perspective and with more love for the individual. I've always been resentful about homosexuality because of what Paul said in his letter to the Romans and the fear of the deterioration of our world because of their open sin/rebellion to God. I was concerned God would destroy our country over such abominations as this. 

Comment by Bill J Green on March 24, 2011 at 6:09pm

There were  some in the Corinthian church just like him, but they were washed!

1 Cor 6:9-11

9 Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders 10 nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. 11 And that is what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.
NIV

Comment by Zonda Bodiford on March 24, 2011 at 11:45am
p.s.  This reminds me of churches that don't allow gays.  What if our church said they would not allow those who had ever sinned?  Same thing, maybe?  I'm so glad I'm not a preacher, and thank God for mine, that he can sort all this out......
Comment by Zonda Bodiford on March 24, 2011 at 11:40am

We are all born sinners.  Through God's grace and mercy via the Holy Spirit, God guides and directs us to walk in the light and obey his laws.  God's forgiveness is vast and ongoing, not to say we are not held accountable for our sins.  Being gay is a sin. So is jealousy, greed, stealing, gossiping, etc.  Have you not baptized others who have committed these sins?  I'm sure everyone that has been baptized has the constant challenge of denying the devil and keeping their heart in God's hands.  But isn't this easier to do when you have the Holy Spirit to guide and help you?  God is the only and final judge.  He relieves us of that task, and I am so glad.  He tells us to love one another and forgive, and not to judge.  

I say consult and study with him, then baptize him, allowing the help of God's Spirit in him for guidance and mercy. 

I can only feel that God would rather have us as his believers, sinners that we are, with faith in him and growing spiritually, than out there, never being baptized, and thus never been given the opportunity of repenting.

Comment by James Nored on March 24, 2011 at 10:02am

Bill, excellent thoughts here. Yes, many do see 1 Peter as a baptismal sermon or teaching section, which is interesting. How do you think that all that you mentioned applies to the questions above?

Comment by James Nored on March 24, 2011 at 10:00am

John, my thoughts are along the lines that you have. Surprise, surprise. We always did think a lot alike. 

However, I do understand Hope's point. If we believe that the Spirit comes into one's life at baptism, then are we denying a person the power to change? Does one have to be fully obedient at baptism?

Comment by Bill Bowman on March 23, 2011 at 9:22pm
In the N.T. baptsim was administered upon one's profession of faith.  Teaching was given after baptism.  Acts 2:42...they continued in the instruction of the apostles. The acceptance of ethical obligations played a part.  Rom. 6:17 "standard of teaching to which you were committed."  Some think that the lst four chapters of I Peter with preaching and ethical instruction was in the context of a baptism...maybe these chapters are used in a baptismal context.  I Peter 1:3 goes back to John 3 about the new birth, baptism.  I Peter 3:21 again reflects on baptism.
Comment by John on March 23, 2011 at 5:23pm
I agree with you on item 1 - a person who states he intends to keep on practicing sinful behavior hasn't repented and therefore isn't a proper candidate for baptism.

Item 2 - Each of us is tempted more strongly to practice some sinful behaviors than others. If a person is attracted to others of the same gender, but recognizes acting on that temptation would be sinful, I would have no problem baptizing such a person. If the person wasn't sure homosexuality was a sin, but agreed to remain celibate, I'd still baptize the person and continue to study. My guess is that any number of us were baptized without a full and complete knowledge of every sinful thought or behavior.

Item 3 - I disagree. Temptation not acted on isn't a sin.

Them's my thoughts.

Latest Activity

BISHOP. MISAKI KYOTO TURNER commented on T.J.R.Benhur Babu's photo
Thumbnail

India mission work

"Father in the name of Jesus Christ restore mobility back too her life restore ordor back and finally This will make a Differance in her hold life Give her you father for my sister Kishinev Davis and my sister tanksley Dovie. Amen"
Jul 22, 2023
BISHOP. MISAKI KYOTO TURNER commented on T.J.R.Benhur Babu's photo
Thumbnail

India mission work

"Bishop loves you All"
Jul 22, 2023
BISHOP. MISAKI KYOTO TURNER posted a status
"Bishop loves you"
Jul 7, 2023
BISHOP. MISAKI KYOTO TURNER commented on T.J.R.Benhur Babu's photo
Thumbnail

India mission work

"We love you All"
Mar 13, 2023

Members

© 2024   Created by James Nored.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service